March is in full spring, and New York is a wonderful place to celebrate St. Paddy's. Bono calls it his adopted home ("The Irish been coming here for years, acting like they own the place") and we aren't hurting for Irish pubs. Beyond shamrocks in the window or "Mcs" in the bar's name, what makes one special? Lads or lasses with adorable accents behind the bar certainly don't hurt.
I also appreciate a well-poured Guinness. (The biggest tip-off that someone is clueless is if they pour it all at once, which makes me cringe).
Beyond my personal preferences, I consulted some of my favorite Irish men, the Shamrock soccer squad (football, as they say) – they’re the oldest continuous Irish team in NYC, and the organization is celebrating its 50th anniversary this year. On any given Sunday, you'll see them running around "the pitch" in Sunnyside and any other time, they're often drinking their way around our fair city :-) The boys (along with some other pint-downing other Irish friends) were generous enough to come up with their list of spots to get your Guinness on. Whether you're game to wrestle your way pasts the amateurs on March 17th, or you'd prefer a quiet pint another night, I hope this list is helpful. Wherever you end up, Sláinte!
1) An Beal Bocht – It’s worth trudging up the hills of Riverdale to reach this gem, which gets my vote for best Irish bar in NYC. Pictures of Irish poets, politicians and news articles grace the wall (as does local artwork in the adjoining room), while cheerful Irish waitresses serve a steady stream of regulars. My go-to order there is a Guinness, along with a (huge) warmed up bowl of rice pudding topped with cinnamon, while Mr. KRey loves their well-seasoned burger.
2) Black Sheep – Park Slope’s very own version of “Cheers,” you’ll likely make friends with the folks at tables nearby, and then put your new friendship to the test over a game of foosball or Scrabble. And who doesn’t love a free jukebox?!
3) Brooklyn Inn -- Casual pool games and high-end beers are among the best offerings at this Boerum Hill favorite, but in all fairness, regulars also warn about weekend crowds and occasionally salty service.
4) Bua – Meaning “victory” in Gaelic, Bua is a win for almost any occasion. Say hello to barkeeps Mikey or Shane and soak up their newly-renovated, comfy East Village space.
5) Courtyard Bar – This list wouldn’t be complete without a special shout out to the Courtyard Bar, the official sponsor of the Shamrock soccer squad. The bar is filled with Irish residents who live in Sunnyside or Woodside, and son of Ireland (and Shamrocks star) Paddy Geraghty often performs his originals or U2 covers on weekends.
6) Cronin & Phelan – The Shamrock’s goalie said “you must include this on the list!” It’s easy to see why: their motto is providing “good food, fine spirits and a damn good decent pint of Guinness.” Take it from the keeper and keep this on your short list if you’re in Queens.
7) Dublin House – This pub doesn’t offer a whole lot in terms of frills or extras, but that didn’t stop many of the Shamrocks from recommending it, commenting that it “it feels just like any place in Ireland…it doesn’t have flash but feels like a proper Irish bar.” And they’re not alone in their approval – the Dublin House has been an Upper West Side fixture since the 1920s.
8) Fiddlesticks – Though Fiddlesticks falls on the more Disney-fied Irish extravaganza décor-wise, the Shamrocks still swear by their all-day Irish breakfast and spacious, relaxed vibe.
9) Galway Hooker – Hey, don’t get offended. In Ireland, a “Galway Hooker” refers to sail boat. But NYers looking for fun (wholesome and un-) can visit either of the G.H. locations (Murray Hill or the West Village), and if you do, ask if Ducky’s around (he’s one of the Shamrocks himself)!
10) Iona – This Williamsburg favorite is named for a Celtic island between Ireland and Scotland, and it’s just one subway stop from the island of Manhattan over in Williamsburg. Old world charm and hipster regulars make for a surprisingly laid-back combo. Irish bartender and owner Ailish also oversaw the addition of a charming back garden.
11) The Gate – Its proximity to Park Slope draws in many teams who want a pint after the game. The friendly atmosphere, craft beer selection and small neighborhood feel keep them coming back.
12) Harefield Road – Irish owner Sean O’Rourke features an impressive craft beer list at this notably unpretentious Williamsburg pub.
13) Johnny’s Bar – This tiny, dive-tastic West Village pub features cheap drinks and flirtatious women behind the bar. The Shamrocks are particularly fond of Christie, who pulls pints after 9:00 p.m. on Fridays.
14) Killarney Rose – This stretch of the financial district can be a bit of a nightlife wasteland, but the Killarney Rose has cheap, decent pub fare and a friendly staff, along with plenty of space.
15) Kinsale Tavern – On the northern end of the Upper East Side lives Kinsale, known for showing all important Gaelic sporting events. Boys from the Shamrocks also noted that their beer is generally cheaper than other nearby spots.
16) McSorley's – Even though they don’t serve Guinness, didn’t let women in for their first 100+ years in business and are often overrun with kids from NYU , my favorite Irish bartender says this is his favorite Irish bar, so it gets a spot on the list. They keep things simple with sawdust on the floor and two choices (of their namesake beer): the light or the dark. One order gets you two small glasses. Note: this isn’t a place to nurse your drink – you’ll be asked to leave if you don’t order another round every 15 minutes or so…so, bottoms up!
17) Milano’s – Only a classic NY Irish pub can be described as “one of our favorite bars…an utter dump” in the same sentence (so said “Not For Tourists). And the Shamrocks agreed. Fancy, it’s not, but fun is always on tap.
18) Molly's Sheeben – Not all the pubs billing themselves as “authentic” Irish bars are, but Molly’s lives up to the claim. Cozy up to the fireplace and sink your teeth into a big bacon cheeseburger with beer-battered onion rings, and keep your ears open for some amazing stories being shared around the bar.
19) Paddy Reilly's Bar – For many years, this Murray Hill staple only served Guinness on tap (they now offer Bud and Bud Light, as well). They also offer live music (the Chieftans used to play here) some nights and open mics on others.
20) Rambling House – The Katonah Avenue stretch of Woodlawn in the Bronx is a hot pocket for Irish bars and entertainment, and the Rambling House is no exception. This bar offers a full bar and restaurant menu, along with unique offerings like harpists during Sunday brunch or “trad-Irish” music by Jameson’s Revenge.
21) Rocky Sullivan’s – Formerly located in Manhattan, Rocky’s moved south along with its owners in 1997, but has kept its boisterous vibe alive in Brooklyn. Oak barrels in the middle of the floor remind you that you’re there to drink, while a colorful Irish mural graces the wall.
22) Rory Dolan's – Unlike some of its cramped city counterparts, this sprawling bar and restaurant on the border of the Bronx and Yonkers has lots of space around the bar, in addition to outdoor seating for sunny days. They also offer live music (often of the Irish variety) almost every night.
23) Tir Na Nog – While this place can be overrun with fans (it’s across the street from Madison Square Garden), its Irish wait staff oversees an efficient, friendly atmosphere where solid portions and reasonable (for Midtown) prices preside.
24) Ulysses – The same guys behind Swift and Puck Fair opened Ulysses. While you may never comprehend the infamously complex novel for which the bar was named, the menu has no confusing subtext. Go for some oysters and anything you fancy from their large beer list. And according to the Shamrocks, ask for Hopper while you’re there.
25) Wilfie and Nell – This West Village pub is owned by Mark and Simon Gibson (who also own Bua, and sister Queens establishment, Sweet Afton) and is named for the brothers’ grandparents – how sweet! But they’ve got more than sweet temperament; they have tempting fare and a menu designed by Brooklyn Star / Momofuku vet Joaquin Baca (you can’t go wrong with Guinness Lamb Shepherd’s Pie).
Where's your favorite place for brogues and beer in NYC?
Leave a comment [4]